Skip to main content View site map
McGarrey's Oakwood Cafe McGarrey's Oakwood Cafe - Homepage
  • Our Menus
  • Call Us
  • Find Us

  • Home
  • Menus
    • Starters and Sides
    • Pizza, Soups and Salads
    • Sandwiches and Burgers
    • Subs
    • Dinners
    • Children's Menu
    • Oakwood Classics
    • In house Menu (PDF)
    • Catering Menu (PDF)
  • Photos
  • Catering
  • Hours & Contact

  • 1624 W. 38th St.
    Erie, PA
  • 814-866-0552

  • Facebook
  • Zomato
  • TripAdvisor
McGarrey's Oakwood Cafe McGarrey's Oakwood Cafe - Homepage

Sandwiches and Burgers

Burgers

  • Additional Toppings

    - Lettuce - Onions - Pickles - Relish - Tomato (.25) - Greek Sauce (1.55)

  • Cheese: American - Provolone - Pepper Jack - Swiss

  • 6 oz. Turkey Burger

    • Price: 7.50
  • 6 oz. Burger

    - Add Cheese 7.85 - Add Cheese and Bacon 8.25 - Add Greek Sauce 1.55

    • Price: 7.50
  • 1/2 lb. Angus Burger

    - Add Cheese 9.50 - Add Cheese and Bacon 9.95 - Add Greek Sauce 1.55

    • Price: 9.15

Sandwiches

  • Hot Dog (1/4 lb.)

    • Price: 5.40
  • Hot Dog 'n' Sauerkraut

    • Price: 6.25
  • Greek Dog

    • Price: 6.95
  • Chicken Fillet with lettuce

    • Price: 8.15
  • Chicken Fillet BLT

    • Price: 9.35
  • Grilled Cheese

    • Price: 4.85
  • Grilled Cheese with Ham or Bacon

    • Price: 6.85
  • Tuna with lettuce

    • Price: 6.45
  • BLT on toast

    • Price: 7.25
  • Corned Beef on Rye

    • Price: 10.65
  • Cold Turkey with lettuce and tomato

    • Price: 6.45
  • Cold Ham and Cheese

    • Price: 6.45
  • Chicken Cordon Bleu

    Chicken breast fillet topped with ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce and tomato

    • Price: 10.25
  • White Fish Fillet

    • Price: 7.85

Club Sandwiches

  • All served on toast with lettuce, tomato and cheese with French fries

  • Bacon Egg

    • Price: 12.95
  • Turkey Bacon

    • Price: 12.95
  • Turkey Ham

    • Price: 12.95

Hot Sandwiches

  • Topped with homemade gravy and served with French fries or mashed potatoes

  • Hot Roast Beef

    • Price: 12.99
  • Baked Meatloaf

    • Price: 12.99
  • Hot Turkey

    Sliced Turkey Breast

    • Price: 12.99
  • Hot Pot Roast

    • Price: 13.75

Grilled Melts

  • All melts are served on grilled Italian bread and served with French

  • Bacon Melt

    Bacon, ham Swiss cheese, lettuce and tomato

    • Price: 13.15
  • Turkey Melt

    Turkey, bacon, Swiss cheese, lettuce and tomato

    • Price: 13.15
  • Combo Melt

    Ham, salami, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato and Italian dressing

    • Price: 13.15
  • Philly Melt

    Shaved steak, provolone cheese, grilled peppers and onions

    • Price: 13.15
  • Corned Beef

    with double Swiss on rye

    • Price: 13.15
  • Breaded Chicken Parmesan

    with provolone cheese

    • Price: 13.15
  • Tuna Fish

    on grilled white bread

    • Price: 13.15
  • Black and Bleu Melt

    6 oz. burger with bleu cheese, lettuce and tomato

    • Price: 13.15
  • Chicken Tender Melt

    Crispy chicken with bacon and melted Pepper Jack Cheese

    • Price: 13.15

Reuben Sandwiches

  • Reuben Sandwich

    Grilled on fresh baked rye, delicious corned beef and fresh sauerkraut topped with Swiss cheese

    • Price: 11.85
  • Turkey Reuben

    Try it with turkey!

    • Price: 11.85
  • Turkey Rachel

    Grilled on fresh baked reuben rye, delicious turkey, and fresh coleslaw topped with swiss cheese

    • Price: 11.85
  • Reuben Platter

    Served with choice of one: French Fries, Deep Fried Onion Rings, Zucchini, Mushrooms, Cauliflower, Deep Fried Green Beans or Sweet Potato Fries

    • Price: 14.99

Specialty Sandwiches

  • Oakwood Deluxe

    Our very own sandwich with 6 oz. burger topped with provolone cheese and mushrooms served with a side of French fries

    • Price: 13.75
  • Oakwood Melt

    A 6 oz. burger with melted Swiss on fresh baked, grilled Rye

    • Price: 8.25
  • Screamin' Oak

    Oakwood's specialty! Turkey breast and jalapeno jack cheese with lettuce and tomato served with a side of French fries

    • Price: 11.50
  • Ox Roast Sandwich

    Top Round

    • Price: 8.25
  • Jumbo Fish

    Hand breaded haddock with French fries

    • Price: 14.55
  • Yuengling Fish

    Beer battered haddock with French fries and coleslaw

    • Price: 14.99
  • Grilled Chicken

    with lettuce and tomato

    • Price: 8.25
  • Grilled Chicken Parmesan

    • Price: 8.75
  • Grilled Cajun Chicken Breast

    with lettuce and tomato

    • Price: 8.25
  • Broiled Cajun Fish

    with French fries

    • Price: 14.55
  • Gyro

    with fres

    • Price: 11.95
  • Kielbasa Sandwich

    with peppers and onions

    • Price: 7.25
  • Filet Croissant

    with provolone and a side of fries

    • Price: 14.50
  • Big BLT

    BLT with 8 pieces of bacon on toasted Italian bread served w/ tater tots

    • Price: 12.75

Select another Menu...

  • Starters and Sides
  • Pizza, Soups and Salads
  • Sandwiches and Burgers
  • Subs
  • Dinners
  • Children's Menu
  • Oakwood Classics
  • In house Menu (PDF)
  • Catering Menu (PDF)
Famous Reuben Sandwich!

Our Menu

8oz Filet

Gift Cards

Please call or stop in.

Bar Room

Hours & Contact

Contact Information

Address

McGarrey's Oakwood Cafe
1624 W. 38th St.
Erie, PA 16508
814-866-0552
Find Us

Hours of Operation

Monday thru Saturday - 11am to 10pm

Sunday - 11am to 8pm

Connect


  • Facebook
  • Zomato
  • TripAdvisor

© 2025 McGarrey's Oakwood Cafe. All rights reserved. | Site map
Websites for Restaurants by Flavor Plate

  • BACK TO TOP
  • Home
  • Menus
  • Photos
  • Catering
  • Hours & Contact